Sunday, September 23, 2012

My Amazon review of Mozart's Don Giovanni

Your reviewing stats
No Profile Image
Reviews written: 5
Reviewer rank: 4,212,662
Would you like to add more to your review?
5.0 out of 5 stars Making Mozart proud, September 23, 2012
By Julianus Dante (So Cal, USA)
Amazon Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Mozart: Don Giovanni (Audio CD)
This is my first experience with a Mozart opera. It's hard getting into it after being so used to the Italian masters. But once I watched a video of the Karajan production and played this over and over, I became truly in love with it. It's long but shock full of great arias, duets and quartets. The more you listen to it, the more its style stays with you and the genius of each piece strikes you. You can see why Mozart is Mozart and influenced all major composers who came after, most noticeably Rossini, who clearly uses musical phrases from here in his own operas, including _The Barber of Seville_. I truly enjoyed hearing the similarities.

I have yet to experience Mozart's other operas but this one will certainly stay with me as a tour de force. Performed well, as it is in this recording, its three-hour length becomes negligible as the stream of events unfold seamlessly towards the great resounding finale with the Commendatore. Still, it's an opera best admired seen first than purely heard and this CD package does not come with a libretto, making it impossible to follow if you're not already familiar with the opera.

Purely as a recording of Don Giovanni, this is quality at its best and will not disappoint. Every voice is in top form and moves masterfully over the vocal challenges presented by Mozart.

My Amazon Review of the Carreras Foscari CD

Your reviewing stats
No Profile Image
Reviews written: 4
Reviewer rank: 4,212,662
Would you like to add more to your review?
Product Image
~Philips
5.0 out of 5 stars (6)
5.0 out of 5 stars The quintessential Foscari, September 23, 2012
By Julianus Dante (So Cal, USA)
Amazon Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Verdi: I due Foscari (Audio CD)
This recording of this obscure early Verdi opera is heavenly. The voices are beautiful and in their prime. Unfortunately, some of the drama is lost as this opera is a less-inspired version of Nabucco and must be seen to appreciate the drama. The music and voices alone don't do the trick. Carreras sounds simply heavenly singing "Dal piu remoto esilio." And Ricciarelli sounds like an angel dropped from the heavens to please our ears with her exquisite voice.

The soprano is in nearly every scene of this opera and, in true Verdi fashion, carries the weight of the opera and is challenged continuously. It may not be his most beautiful sounding opera, but it's certainly not any easier on the voices. You truly have to be a master to pull this opera off. It's quickly become one of my favorites, both for its rarity and theme.

There is still plenty of Verdi to enjoy here. He does some amazing transitions, has a powerful prelude, and gives the Doge, Jacopo, Lucrezia and the Council of Ten each their own theme music that adds a dramatic quality to an otherwise uneventful opera. I'm proud to own it.

My Amazon Review of Verdi's The Two Foscari

Your reviewing stats
No Profile Image
Reviews written: 3
Reviewer rank: 4,212,662
Would you like to add more to your review?
Product Image
~BBC / Opus Arte
4.0 out of 5 stars (12)
4.0 out of 5 stars Quality Singing, Meager Staging, September 23, 2012
By Julianus Dante (So Cal, USA)
Amazon Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Verdi - I Due Foscari / Bruson, Roark-Strummer, Cupido, Roni, Gavazzeni, La Scala Opera (DVD)
I just saw the LA Opera's production of this rare Verdi opera starring Placido Domingo and while the LA Opera's production design and costumes are far superior to this 80's La Scala production, the voices in this video are far superior. Renato Bruson does great early-Verdi. I have La Scala's production of Nabucco with him and he never disappoints.

The production design on this stage is very sparse and makes it hard to get into this already obscure opera, but if you love Verdi and the challenges he gives his sopranos as well as the seamless way in which he goes from a duetto to a terzetto to a quartet, this production demonstrates it effortlessly. Bruson definitely steals the show in the finale.

To his credit, Placido does the same in the LA Opera's production but he definitely tires faster in his old age. His theatricality, however, is matchless! One hopes they have a DVD of the production for the sake of the costumes and production design. The soprano and tenor, however, leave much to be desired. Alas! A great age of operatic voices has ended.